Defendants.
Attachment Description
- Attachment 1 - December 19, 2022 ICL Executive Leadership / “Borden Ave” email chain.
- Attachment 2 - December 20–21, 2022 ICL “Two Deaths in Two Weeks” / overdose-task-force email chain.
- Attachment 3- March 27, 2023 Pena Borden Avenue complaint to NYC DVS with photographic exhibits.
- Attachment 4 - March 27–29, 2023 D’Mello / DVS response and meeting correspondence.
- Attachment 5 - March 29, 2023 Hendon response identifying DHS oversight of the ICL-operated facility.
- Attachment 6 - March 27–29, 2023 consolidated DVS/Hendon Borden correspondence.
- Attachment 7 - June 6, 2023 Pena VTF email concerning homeless veteran advocacy and request for assistance.
- Attachment 8 - June 6, 2023 Russell response concerning Pena’s characterization of the shelter action.
- Attachment 9 - June 6, 2023 Russell communication to VTF concerning Pena’s account.
- Attachment 10 - June 7, 2023 Pena continued VTF advocacy concerning homeless-veteran and program issues.
- Attachment 11 - June 7, 2023 Fuller direction to stop the group-email discussion.
- Attachment 12 - June 7, 2023 Russell endorsement of Fuller’s intervention.
- Attachment 13 - June 9, 2023 Pena continued advocacy.
- Attachment 14 - June 9, 2023 Fuller warning concerning “disparag[ing] agencies” and possible step-down.
- Attachment 15 - July 3, 2023 Russell communication characterizing Pena’s communications as “continued rhetoric and untruths.”
- Attachment 16 - July 3, 2023 Fuller communication objecting to criticism involving DHS colleagues.
- Attachment 17 - July 3, 2023 Pena response concerning DHS/Borden advocacy and PTSD/disability.
- Attachment 18 - July 5, 2023 Russell restriction on Pena’s use of the VTF distribution list.
- Attachment 19 - May 7, 2024 Pena request for formal VA complaint concerning Borden.
- Attachment 20 - May 7, 2024 Fuller confirmation that Pena’s complaints had been sent to DHS.
- Attachment 21 - May 30, 2024 Pena email to VA GPD National Office / FOIA request concerning Borden.
- Attachment 22 - May 30, 2024 Erin E. Johnson response identifying local VA medical-center oversight of the grant.
- Attachment 23 - July 16, 2024 Pena VTF performance email / “total and complete failure.”
- Attachment 24 - July 31, 2024 VTF Written Warning issued by Santiago and Wawrynek.
- Attachment 25 - July 31, 2024 Pena response invoking First Amendment concerns and PTSD/disability.
- Attachment 26 - September 18–19, 2024 resignation demand/request and Pena’s refusal.
- Attachment 27 - September 26, 2024 VTF removal notice.
- Attachment 28 - NYC Continuum of Care Veterans Task Force Committee Agreement.
- Attachment 29 - NYC Continuum of Care governance / Steering Committee / VTF governing provisions.
- Attachment 30 - VA OIG and VA FOIA materials: 30-A VA_OIG_Hotline_20240614; 30-B FOIA Request 24-15366- F; 30-C FOIA Request 24-16958-F; 30-D VAOIG-11-03428-173; 30-E vaoig-23-02610-226.
- Attachment 31 - Recent NYPD FOIL emergency-call and arrest records and related financial/community- impact analyses.
- Attachment 32 - A Tale of Two Transitional Programs — Pena’s Borden/Phoenix comparative advocacy presentation.
- Attachment 33 - Various Articles from local journalists and media outlets
Defendants.
This page provides public access to the Second Amended Complaint and supporting Appendices A–F filed in Pena v. City of New York, et al., Case No. 26-CV-0176 (JMF), in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York.
The supporting record consists of Attachments 1–33, including contemporaneous emails, Veterans Task Force records, governmental correspondence, VA oversight and FOIA materials, NYC Continuum of Care governing documents, and public-record materials relevant to the allegations in the Complaint.
These materials are provided to maintain an organized and accessible record of the documents submitted in connection with the litigation.
Letter to the SDNY Federal Court Case: 26-CV-0176
(Revised) SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT - September 3, 2026 (pdf)
The Appendices are organized as follows:
Appendix A — Early Notice and Advocacy: Attachments 1–5
Appendix B — Veterans Task Force Speech and Restrictions: Attachments 6–18
Appendix C — Continuing Governmental Notice and VA Oversight: Attachments 19–22
Appendix D — Written Warning and Removal: Attachments 23–27
Appendix E — Governing and Corroborating Documents: Attachments 28–32
Appendix F — Various Articles from Local Journalists: Attachment 33
Full List of Attachments: 1 - 33
Second Amended Complaint - August 26, 2026
Appendix A — Veterans Task Force Discipline and Removal Record: VTF Committee Agreement/Code of Conduct, written warning, resignation/removal communications, NYC Continuum of Care bylaws and governance materials, and records concerning VTF participation and removal procedures.
Appendix B — Email Correspondence and Retaliation Chronology: Contemporaneous correspondence documenting Pena's advocacy, complaints concerning Borden Avenue and homeless veterans, VTF communications, restrictions on communications, disciplinary actions, and the events leading to removal.
Appendix C — Disability, PTSD, and Participant-Rights Materials: Records concerning Pena's disclosure of PTSD, disability-related communications, VTF disciplinary and mediation provisions, and related participant-rights materials.
Appendix D — Pre-Litigation Comparative Advocacy: Materials demonstrating Pena's advocacy concerning Borden Avenue and comparison of veteran transitional-housing programs before this litigation.
Appendix E — VA GPD Statutes, Regulations, and Program Requirements: Federal statutory, regulatory, and VA program materials concerning the Grant and Per Diem program, including relevant provisions of 38 C.F.R. Part 61.
Appendix F — VA FOIA, GPD, and OIG Oversight Materials: VA FOIA requests and responses, GPD records, VA Office of Inspector General materials, and records documenting Pena's efforts to seek federal review and oversight.
Appendix G — Borden Avenue Safety and Incident Records: NYPD FOIL emergency-call and arrest records and other materials concerning incidents and safety conditions at 21-10 Borden Avenue.
Appendix H — DHS/City Administration and Oversight Materials: New York City governmental records, hearings, and other materials concerning Borden Avenue, veteran homelessness, and municipal oversight.
Appendix I — ICL Operations, Notice, and Organizational Records: Institute for Community Living correspondence and records relevant to ICL's notice of Pena's concerns and the operation of Borden Avenue.
Appendix J — Comparative Transitional-Housing Materials: Materials concerning MANA House and other comparative veteran transitional-housing programs relevant to the substance and context of Pena's advocacy.
Appendix K — Historical and Investigative Materials: Historical reporting, Pena's pre-litigation public advocacy, and other investigative materials offered for the limited purposes identified in the complaint and appendix index.
